Faculty Digital Archive

Archive@NYU >
Stern School of Business >
CeDER Published Papers >

Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: http://hdl.handle.net/2451/27766

Title: The Myth of the Double-Blind Review? Author Identification Using Only Citations
Authors: Provost, Foster
Hill, Shawndra
Keywords: KDD Cup Competition
author identification
social network analysis
relational learning
vector-space model
discriminative self-citations
Issue Date: 1-Jun-2003
Publisher: SIGKDD Explorations
Citation: Volume 5, Issue 2 - Page 179
Series/Report no.: CeDER-PP-2003-01
Abstract: Prior studies have questioned the degree of anonymity of the double-blind review process for scholarly research articles. For example, one study based on a survey of reviewers concluded that authors often could be identified by reviewers using a combination of the author's reference list and the referee's personal background knowledge. For the KDD Cup 2003 competition's "Open Task" we examined how well various automatic matching techniques could identify authors within the competition's very large archive of research papers. This paper describes the issues surrounding author identification, how these issues motivated our study, and the results we obtained. The best method, based on discriminative self-citations, identified authors correctly 40-45% of the time. One main motivation for double-blind review is to eliminate bias in favor of well-known authors. However, identification accuracy for authors with substantial publication history is even better (60% accuracy for the top-10% most prolific authors, 85% for authors with 100 or more prior papers).
URI: http://hdl.handle.net/2451/27766
Appears in Collections:CeDER Published Papers

Files in This Item:

File Description SizeFormat
CPP-01-03.pdf199.63 kBAdobe PDFView/Open

Items in Faculty Digital Archive are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.


The contents of the FDA may be subject to copyright, be offered under a Creative Commons license, or be in the public domain.
Please check items for rights statements. For information about NYU’s copyright policy, see http://www.nyu.edu/footer/copyright-and-fair-use.html 
Valid XHTML 1.0 | CSS